go-witness is Vulnerable to Improper Verification of AWS EC2 Identity Documents

Impact

This vulnerability only affects users of the AWS attestor.

Users of the AWS attestor could have unknowingly received a forged identity document. While this may seem unlikely, AWS recently issued a security bulletin about IMDS (Instance Metadata Service) impersonation.[^1]

There are multiple locations where the verification of the identity document will mistakenly report a successful verification.

• If a signature is not present or is empty https://github.com/in-toto/go-witness/blob/0c8bb30c143951d88b1d4b32f260c5f67d30137b/attestation/aws-iid/aws-iid.go#L161-L163

• If the RSA verification of the document fails for any reason https://github.com/in-toto/go-witness/blob/0c8bb30c143951d88b1d4b32f260c5f67d30137b/attestation/aws-iid/aws-iid.go#L192-L196

Workarounds

The contents of the AWS attestation contain the identity document, signature, and public key that was used to verify the document. These attestations and their could be identity documents could be manually verified with the openssl command line as documented in the below reference from AWS.[^2]

However, the certificate containing the public key was hard-coded into the attestor. https://github.com/in-toto/go-witness/blob/0c8bb30c143951d88b1d4b32f260c5f67d30137b/attestation/aws-iid/aws-iid.go#L46-L66

Since the original authoring of the attestor, AWS has moved to region specific public certificates. The currently valid certificates were issued around April of 2024, making the identification of attestations with forged content difficult without additional trusted data proving the AWS region in which the attestation was created.

Patches

This vulnerability is addressed in go-witness 0.9.1 and witness 0.10.1.

Resources

[^1]: AWS Security Bulletin on IMDS Impersonation [^2]: Verification of instance identity documents